When utilizing this therapy, psychotherapists use sand trays to assess, diagnose, or treat a variety of mental illnesses. Research shows that sand tray therapy can help increase emotional expression while reducing the psychological distress that may come from discussing traumatic events or experiences. Sand tray therapy was developed by Dora Kalff, who was inspired by working with Margaret Lowenfeld, a British child psychiatrist and developer of World Technique. Kalff’s Jungian-based theory also was influenced by Buddhist contemplative practices. Sand tray therapy is based on the notion that if a therapist provides the client with a safe space, the client will use the sand tray to create solutions to their problems on their own.
Types of Play Therapy
Sand tray therapy is a type of play therapy. Other common types of play therapy include:
Bibliotherapy, which uses literature to explore specific concepts or skills Cognitive behavioral play therapy, which uses play to help a child learn how to think and behave differently (such as asking the child to give their doll or stuffed animal advice on how to handle a stressful situation) Filial therapy, which aims to teach parents how to interact with the child through play Imaginary play, which uses toys, such as dress-up clothing, puppets, or action figures, to spark a child’s imagination
Techniques
Sand tray therapy is a combination of play therapy and art therapy. The therapist provides the client with a tray or box filled with sand as well as a variety of miniature toys to create a play world. Toys may include anything from farm animals and dinosaurs to people and cars. Trees, fences, gates, doors, and buildings are common as well. Those who offer this type of therapy believe clients will create a world that represents their internal struggles or conflicts. After the sandplay is complete, the therapist and client typically discuss what was observed—the toys that were chosen, how they were arranged, and any symbolic or metaphorical meanings. The client may then choose to rearrange the toys based on the discussion. Sand tray therapy may also include talk therapy, other types of play or art therapy, or other types of treatment.
What Sand Tray Therapy Can Help With
Sandplay therapy has been shown to benefit the following issues:
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) Aggression Anger management Anxiety disorders Autism spectrum disorder Depression Divorce Grief and loss Low self-esteem Physical and learning disabilities School-related problems Social issues Trauma and crisis
Benefits of Sand Tray Therapy
Research shows that sand tray therapy reduces symptoms of many mental health issues and increases resilience. Because sandplay therapy is unstructured, it allows clients to experience healing through the therapeutic process. Sandplay also may help therapists delve into the meanings that clients develop and assign to their experiences by monitoring their engagement with the toys, or symbols they choose to play with. Additionally, sandplay therapy is often a pleasurable sensory experience facilitating the natural expression of emotions. It may be used as part of individual, group, or family therapy.
Effectiveness
Studies show sand trays are an effective way to treat a variety of problems and can be used in many different populations.
A study in Korea found that sandplay therapy as part of school counseling led to improved self-esteem and significant changes in emotional problems in fourth and fifth graders. A study conducted on 4- and 5-year-old children with externalizing behavior problems demonstrated that these children showed less aggressive behavior after 30 minutes of group sandplay. They participated in therapy twice a week for 16 sessions. Another small study in Korea included three children who had witnessed domestic violence. It found that supportive music and imagery combined with sandplay therapy improved emotional and behavioral adaptability after six individual sessions. Meanwhile, another study evaluated sandplay of migrant women in Korea. The researchers found that group sandplay therapy produced positive self-expression and reduced negative self-expression. In China, a study involving boys with Asperger’s syndrome, a diagnosis that the DSM-5 has since retired and today would be considered level one autism spectrum disorder (ASD), combined sandplay therapy with other forms of treatment. It concluded that sandplay therapy helped develop the boys’ psychological well-being and interpersonal communication skills. Researchers theorize that sandplay therapy may help vulnerable, pre-verbal children with trauma, making it a good strategy for those who are too young to talk about their traumatic experience. A study supporting this theory was conducted on a 3-year-old orphan with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Researchers found that sandplay therapy provided the child with emotional support.
Things to Consider
Some people view sand tray therapy as confusing and time-consuming or too dependent on the therapist’s clinical expertise, noting that the interpretations of sand pictures may be vague or ambiguous. In addition, adults who lack creativity may be resistant to this form of therapy. It’s not uncommon to wonder how using miniature toys in the sand is helping resolve any issues. But sandplay therapy can provide therapists an inside look into things that may be troubling their clients. It’s especially useful for people who have trouble communicating about stressors. When sandplay therapy is used as part of a treatment plan, the therapist may provide a sand tray and then look for common themes that indicate insecurities or aggressive behavior, as well as resilience and positive emotional expression. If you’re concerned about the effectiveness of the treatment, express your concerns to your therapist. Together, you can come up with a treatment plan that meets your needs.
How to Get Started
If you think that you or a loved one might benefit from sand tray therapy, start by talking to your physician. Your doctor may be able to refer you to a local therapist.
Find a certified professional. While any psychotherapist may be able to provide sand tray therapy, some therapists are specifically certified in sandplay therapy. Sandplay Therapists of America offers a directory of certified sandplay therapists. Call your health insurance. Inquire whether sand tray therapy is covered by your health insurance and, if not, whether the therapist accepts payment on a sliding scale. Know what to expect. Sand tray sessions may be 30 to 60 minutes in length and scheduled weekly or bi-weekly. After arriving for a session, your therapist greets you and provides you with an empty sand tray and miniatures so you can get to work. The therapist may ask to photograph your sand trays so the changes in the scenes you create can be reviewed over time. Be prepared to answer questions. At the end of each session, your therapist may take time to talk about your sand tray. For example, they might discuss what it might mean if the domesticated animals in your sand tray are caged while the more dangerous animals get to roam free. Together, you may find some meaning in the sand tray. It’s also possible that there will be little discussion at all. Instead, the therapist may simply give you a safe space to work.
